Bing It On

Ziggy · Oct 11, 2013

Google changed the algorithm in a significant way recently - Hummingbird - and focuses more on semantic search. Any case study that includes research from over a month ago is now worthless.

Air Langhi · Oct 11, 2013

bing won 0 rounds

AMS · Oct 11, 2013

theogcasey said: ↑

Well, the Internet Explorer 10 banner was a dead giveaway...
Click to expand...

lol, this

VBG · Oct 11, 2013

http://freakonomics.com/2013/10/01/challenging-the-bing-it-on-challenge/

Challenging the Bing-It-On Challenge
IAN AYRES
10/01/2013 | 11:02 am PRINT
SHARE

Did you find this blog post through Bing? Probably not — 67% of worldwide searches go through Google, 18% through Bing. But Microsoft has advertised in a substantial TV campaign that — in the cyber analog to blind taste-testing — people prefer Bing “nearly 2:1.” A year ago, when I first saw these ads, the 2-1 claim seemed implausible. I would have thought the search results of these competitors would be largely identical, and that it would be hard for people to distinguish between the two sets of results, much less prefer one kind 2:1.
When I looked into the claim a bit more, I was slightly annoyed to learn that the “nearly 2:1” claim is based on a study of just 1,000 participants. To be sure, I’ve often published studies with similarly small data sets, but it’s a little cheeky for Microsoft to base what might be a multi-million dollar advertising campaign on what I’m guessing is a low-six-figure study.
To make matters worse, Microsoft has refused to release the results of its comparison website, BingItOn.com. More than 5 million people have taken the Bing-It-On challenge – which is the cyber analog to a blind taste test. You enter in a search term and the Bing-It-On site return two panels with de-identified Bing and Google results (randomly placed on the right or left side of the screen). You tell the site which side’s results you prefer and after five searches the site reveals whether you prefer Bing or Google (see below).
Microsoft’s ads encourage users to join the millions of people who have taken the challenge, but it will not reveal whether the results of the millions are consistent with the results of the 1,000.
bing
So together with four Yale Law students, I set up a similar-sized experiment using Microsoft’s own BingItOn.com site to see which search engine users prefer. We found that, to the contrary of Microsoft’s claim, 53 percent of subjects preferred Google and 41 percent Bing (6 percent of results were “ties”). This is not even close to the advertised claim that people prefer Bing “nearly two-to-one.” It is misleading to have advertisements that say people prefer Bing 2:1 and also say join the millions of people who’ve taken the Bing-It-On challenge, if, as in our study, the millions of people haven’t preferred Bing at a nearly a 2:1 rate. Microsoft might have realized this and has more recently altered its advertising to back off their original claim to just say that people “prefer” Bing.
We also interjected a bit of randomness into our study to test whether the type of search term impacts the likelihood that Bing is preferred. We randomly assigned participants to search for one of three kinds of keywords: Bing’s suggested search terms, popular search terms, and self-suggested search terms. When Bing-suggested search terms were used the two engines statistically tied (47% preferring Bing vs. 48% preferring Google). But when the subjects in the study suggested their own searches or used the web’s most popular searches, a sizable gap appeared: 55-57% preferred Google while only 35-39% preferred Bing. These secondary tests indicate that Microsoft selected suggested search words that it knew were more likely to produce Bing-preferring results. You can read our full paper here.
The upshot: several of Microsoft’s claims are a little fishy. Or to put the conclusion more formally, we think that Google has a colorable deceptive advertising claim against Microsoft. It could be worth a lot of money on lost ad revenue if the claims misled people into thinking that a substantial majority of people prefer Bing over Google. Then again, I might be a little over zealous in seeing Lanham Act violations. Back in 2010, I suggested that the movie Date Night might contain a deceptive Kindle ad.
Click to expand...

dsnow23 · Oct 11, 2013

Bing 3. google 1. 1 draw.

Jontro · Oct 11, 2013

What's going on?? What the hell is bing? I'm evacuating as we speak.

bigtexxx · Oct 11, 2013

I stick to Ask Jeeves exclusively

BamBam · Oct 11, 2013

I exclusively answer questions for Jeeves....
.......
.......
.......

ima_drummer2k · Oct 11, 2013

I typically use AOL keywords.

tmoney1101 · Oct 11, 2013

bing won but it's only because 3 out of 5 searches i did were for p*rn related content and bing had pics.

FLASH21 · Oct 11, 2013

Google me b****.

3-2

Haymitch · Oct 11, 2013

On a related note, I've probably watched Bring It On all the way through 3 or 4 times.

Also good was Bring It On: All or Nothing, though I think I only watched it once.

JuanValdez · Oct 11, 2013

Draw every time. Does it really matter too much?

KaiSeR SoZe · Oct 11, 2013

I got bing, surprisingly.

RocketRaccoon · Oct 11, 2013

BING!

calurker · Aug 14, 2014

So has anyone kept up with using Bing since? Does it/has it gotten better? Here in China, I'm stuck with the dumb-and-dumberer choices of Bing and Baidu, and I swear Bing is downright brain dead r****ded. Last night trying to search for "how does Kingsoft make money" (no quotation marks) on Bing returned the top result of "Where does Microsoft make money?", and only 2 results on the first page were about Kingsoft, the rest were about Microsoft. I mean, WTF? How stupid is their search engine? The whole department should be fired, Nokia-style.

peleincubus · Aug 14, 2014

Invisible Fan said: ↑

Taste test happens in isolation, so the sweeter tasting generally wins.

Coke has a complex and nuanced flavor that lasts longer. It's more distinct, which definitely helps with the branding.

<~~coke all the way
Click to expand...

Yeah wasn't that in a gladwell book. People liked the initial taste of Pepsi better but liked come after the can was open for a little while and also after the first couple of drinks.

Invisible Fan · Aug 14, 2014

^It was

As for search engine, I use DuckDuckGo for normal stuff and the search bar (extension) because I'm logged on gmail. It's probably 60% effective as google, but I like consented privacy (better pay me to data mine me) and I still have incognito mode...

Dave_78 · Aug 14, 2014

Bing - 3
Draw - 2
Google - 0

Ericstocracy · Aug 14, 2014

Google 5-0

Always use google, won't change now.

Forums

Bing It On

Which Search Engine Won?

Google

Bing

Draw

Ziggy QUEEN ANON

Air Langhi Contributing Member

AMS Member

VBG Member

dsnow23 Member

Jontro Member

bigtexxx Member

BamBam Member

ima_drummer2k Member

tmoney1101 Member

FLASH21 Heart O' Champs

Haymitch Custom Title

JuanValdez Member

KaiSeR SoZe Member

RocketRaccoon Contributing Member

calurker Member

peleincubus Member

Invisible Fan Member

Dave_78 Member

Ericstocracy Member

Share This Page

About ClutchFans

Rockets Content

Support ClutchFans!