Which Astros pitcher would you want in a must win?

This is really tough one. It's between Andy and Roger, Roy didn't have his best stuff in last year's playoffs (6.75 ERA in the LCS, 4.19 ERA in 4 games, only won 1). Roger has had an amazing season, he had an ERA under 4 (3.60) in 4 games in last year's playoff's, and he has had consistent (good) performances in most of his series, including the World Series. However, I have to give it to Andy. He was on fire in 2003 for the Yankees in the post season, including a 0.57 ERA in the World Series (in 2 games) and a 2 ERA in the 5 games he started before the WS; Not to mention the guy is heating up again, and we just always seem to win with him pitching, give me Andy.

Edit: and for some reason I thought that said game 7 of the WS. Nevertheless it's a big game, and Andy is known as a good big game pitcher.

 

I picked Roger, however this season seems like I should have picked Roy or Andy since they get more run support.

Roger is so intimidating he scares off our bats!

 

It's not Roger's fault for the lack of run support when he pitches.

 

Bob Knepper.

 

Would you have let Knepper pitch the ninth, or go to Dave Smith?

METS 9TH: WALLING STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING 3B); DYKSTRA BATTED
FOR AGUILERA; Dykstra tripled to center; Wilson singled to right
[Dykstra scored]; Mitchell grounded out (third to first) [Wilson
to second]; Hernandez doubled to center [Wilson scored]; SMITH
REPLACED KNEPPER (PITCHING); Carter walked; Strawberry walked
[Hernandez to third, Carter to second]; Knight hit a sacrifice
fly to right [Hernandez scored, Carter to third, Strawberry to
second]; BACKMAN BATTED FOR TEUFEL; Backman was walked
intentionally; HEEP BATTED FOR SANTANA; Heep struck out; 3 R, 3
H, 0 E, 3 LOB. Mets 3, Astros 3.

 

Mike Scott, 1986, 18-10, 2.22 ERA

Nothin' like a little scuffin' to seal a win!

 

I am biased toward Andy, because he grew up on the street behind me. At this point I would have to choose Clemens.

Roy is a great pitcher, but it seems as his attitude can change at any second. This is not a good trait for a pitcher. He helps lead the team, and a bad attitude will spread faster than herpes at a bordello.

 

I am biased toward Andy, because he grew up on the street behind me. At this point I would have to choose Clemens.

Roy is a great pitcher, but it seems as his attitude can change at any second. This is not a good trait for a pitcher. He helps lead the team, but a the same time the bad attitude will spread faster than herpes at a bordello.