2025 Baseball Season

13 morons should lose their vote, how judge wasn’t unanimous is mind blowing

 

What does "Most Valuable" mean?

 

Whoever had the highest war is the most valuable. Any other interpretation is flat out stupid.

 

If that's your criteria then you're talking about "Best Player" not "Most Valuable"

You do understand that those are two different things, right?

 

Someone with a war of 7 cannot be more valuable than someone with a war of 8. It's impossible.

 

I bet your fantasy league team kicks all kinds of ass.

 

oh man, last time i did fantasy baseball is probably 20 years ago, even football i stopped years ago

 

Exactly, a catcher that did the things Raleigh did this year is far more valuable than what Judge did IMHO. Great defensive player and did historic things with the bat for the catcher position.

 

The only issue is that cal was inarguably less valuable. That’s a fact. Why would you want a less valuable player winning mvp over a more valuable player?

 

Gonna cry?

 

Well Seattle can join us in hating Chandler Rome together

 

Good. Couldn’t have the guy with the worst nickname in all of sports winning.

 

"us"?

 

MLB sucks, Judge given a fraudulent MVP, the Dodgers well over a half billion in payroll (see deferred payments) buying championships. What a crock.

Keep up the great work Manfred.

 

Because of positional value I would argue that Cal was the MVP.

 

That’s simply factually wrong. War takes position into account and he was less valuable than judge. It’s not an opinion, it’s an indisputable fact. You can say you don’t like judge and want someone else to win, or you like cal so you want him to win. What you absolutely cannot say is cal deserved to win, there is no argument for that.

 

Another reason I think trading Diaz is a mistake. At some point, his bat is going to become more steady. Caratini really should be a backup catcher.

 

Maybe MLB should just give the award to the WAR leader… or make a separate award for the WAR leader every year?